The more protein present, the higher the market price.

Outsourcing to China seems to be the answer. They apparently are very knowledgeable and creative in finding cheap protein sources. As you probably know, meat is the most expensive ingredient in dog food.


Remember the nationwide recall of contaminated pet food in March 2007? Many dogs and cats died of kidney failure after eating melamine-contaminated pet food.

Melamine is a nitrogen-rich compound and when added to milk powder (for instance), the protein amounts measured in standard protein assays are inflated. Melamine is used to produce plastics and has nothing to do with being nutritious in the first place. In fact, it appeared to be toxic as hell!

Since then, melamine continues to be found in milk and other foods such as rice protein concentrate and corn gluten.

Several baby’s in Asia died of acute kidney failure only one year after the same unscrupulous practice killed dogs and cats.

More advanced protein assays differentiate between real protein and melamine, so switch to leather waste instead?

Now leather scraps have been found in batches of dairy products produced in Zhejiang, China. An anonymous letter was sent in to China’s quality watchdog, upon which 5 out of 8 batches were tested positive for this contamination.

It’s a real protein for sure, but it has nothing to do with producing nutritious food. Adding hydrolyzed leather protein to food will boost protein content but this powder is toxic and hazardous to one’s health. As the source of the protein was dirty hydrolyzed leather waste, it also contained potassium dichromate and sodium dichromate.

As this is a real protein, in contrast to melamine, it is more difficult to detect.

False advertising and use of potentially dangerous ingredients

Last month I received an email from a Chinese guy. His family owns a business that manufactures ingredients for dog food and dog treats. He exposed their American client that allegedly ordered them to irradiate all chicken meat and, for financial reasons, use only 65% chicken and the remainder should be: non-fowl filler including melamine, peanuts, bone fragment powder etc. Furthermore, he reported that the advertising and label listed use of vitamins and herbs though these were not inside the package (the costs would be too high, he explained).

Reason for his sudden openness is that their contract was recently terminated after four years. He considers this an unfair blow to their business after following exact instructions by the owner and founder.

I have not published the mail and the company names he sent me because I cannot verify his accusations. I’ve asked him to sent me a copy of the order in which the American company specifies which ingredients to use. Also, I’ve asked him why he thought it was OK to put toxic ingredients in food as long as he got paid to do that.

No answer up until today.

We must all make a living and earn money, but this should not be accomplished by putting other people and animals at risk. The Chinese government has their own method of dealing with dissidents. Recently two man were sentenced to death because of their involvement in the melamine-tainted milk scandal that sickened 294000 infants and killed six others. Nevertheless, the leather protein incident is yet another embarrassing failure for China’s product safety system.

The FDA now has three food safety offices in China to inspect food and liaise with Chinese officials.

Good food requires good ingredients and the absence of toxic compounds. There is no shortcut!!




Other articles that may interest you:
Would you pay more for local grown dog food ingredients?
Why is pentobarbital found in dog food?

{ 0 comments }

The history of dog food

by Barbara on May 13, 2009

in Dog Food Market Research

A brief overview of the history of dog food:

{ 1 comment }

Bloat in Dogs

May 6, 2009

My Akita dog Kensho gives a clear demonstration: you play first, and only then..  you eat. When eating, chew your food carefully (don’t fall into that typical gorging behavior that give dogs a bad name as diner companions).

Why is this good behavior?
Play reduces stress and the risk of developing gastric torsion is reduced when your [...]

Read the full article →

Renal failure in young dog - always consult a vet!

April 26, 2009

Today I got a question via my website Best Dog Food Guide of a desperate dog owner.
I have a 5 yr. old Doberman that is in Renal failure. I need to buy the best dog food for him. I also want the best meds I can put him on OR make it for him…Will he [...]

Read the full article →

Probiotic Patent Dispute in Dog Food Land - Nestle/Purina vs. Wysong

February 17, 2009

Who has invented probiotic enriched dog food?
Well… that’s the question. Who was first to use this technology? Who was first in patenting it? In this case the answer differs which is why these companies are in battle.
Who was the first to produce probiotic enriched dog food?
Dr Wysong has enriched pet food, as well as human [...]

Read the full article →

Why NOT feed your dog cooked chicken bones?

January 16, 2009

Paul from South Africa asked this question using the contact form on Best Dog Food Guide.
“I have been feeding my dogs raw and cooked chicken bones for over 3 years now. Never had a problem. Both were strays so I know they have been eating the same or much worse in the past. That means [...]

Read the full article →

My Akita Won’t Eat The Dog Food I Buy!

December 5, 2008

The other day I received the following question from Chris (USA):
What do you feed your Akita?
I’m having a problem finding a food my Akita “likes.”
He never seems to WANT to eat only if I force him too.
He gets plenty of exercise just doesn’t like the foods I’ve had him on (Solid Gold, Innova).
Do you [...]

Read the full article →

Getting Your Dog To Loose Weight Is Not Easy

June 15, 2008

Via the contact form of Best Dog Food Guide I received the following question:
My dog is overweight by at least 15 pounds. I have cut down on his food intake and also do more walks with him. The problem is I cannot go for long walks. Two back surgeries have limited me in walking very [...]

Read the full article →

Timberwolf Organics Dry Dog Food - Voluntary Recall

June 8, 2008

Due to complaints of sick dogs from customers - Timberwolf Organics Dog Food has voluntarily recalled two brands of dry dog food.

Dakota Bison with ‘best by’ date of 12 February 2009

Ocean Blue with ‘best by’ date of 20 February 2009 and 8 March 2009.

The reported symptoms in dogs include:

Dogs refusing to eat (just being smart [...]

Read the full article →

More Single Households Equals More Dog Food Sales

May 24, 2008

The market for dog and cat food continues to grow. In 2007 the worldwide retail sales exceeded 45 billion US dollars (Euromonitor International). This represents a total growth of about 40% as compared to 2002.Of course this can’t go on at such rates though analysts predict the dog and cat food will continue to grow [...]

Read the full article →

Next Dog Top Model

May 5, 2008

T-Nell, a semi professional photographer, she also happens to by my aunt , has chosen a picture of Kensho to participate in a photo contest. This contest is held by Canon and you can vote as per May, 5th 2008. Please visit the photo contest website and help to get this picture of Kensho [...]

Read the full article →

Is Your Dog Training You?

May 3, 2008

Dog owners often run into the same issues and I can relate to them from experience. I have fallen for the same tricks when Kensho played them on me.

Question from a desperate dog owner:
“My 7 month old pup is more than picky when it comes to her food! She just doesn’t LIKE any of it, [...]

Read the full article →

Will Your Dog Benefit From Diabetic Dog Food?

April 27, 2008

Canine diabetes is becoming a lifestyle disease in dogs just like in humans. The risk for developing diabetes mellitus increases with age and weight.

Early warning signs include extreme thirst and increased water intake (and hence more frequent urinating), unexplained weight loss and depressed or lethargic behavior.
The usual treatment consists of strictly regulating sugar intake. This [...]

Read the full article →

Dental Care for Dogs - Avoiding that notorious “Doggy Breath”

March 22, 2008

Kyle from the USA posted the following question to ‘Best Dog Food Guide‘:
“I’ve been told dry dog food is good for my dogs teeth. Is putting water in his food bowl all the time going to take away from this?”
Well, the short answer is a plain ‘no’. I’m assuming Kyle is worried about his [...]

Read the full article →

Pet Food Safety Off the Radar?

March 15, 2008

The Great Dog Food Scare is now one year away. In the first months a lot of websites and blogs were writing about this topic and many more people were searching for information to find safe dog food.
Menu Foods stock was sent into a free fall and faces more than 100 class-action lawsuits. Last month, [...]

Read the full article →